Anything Engine Optimization The rolling record of the AI-search industry.
Close-up of abstract architectural elements creating geometric patterns in soft blue tones.
Photo by David Yu on Pexels
self-published analyst data — Lily Ray/Amsive, 100 queries in one vertical; contradicted by Kevin Indig's 62% traffic-gain finding and Scrunch's 24.3% competitor-recommendation rate
PPC Land · Oct 5 ResearchAEOGoogle Search

AI Overviews cite self-ranked 'best of' pages less, Lily Ray finds

What this answers

Does Google AI Overviews penalize brands that rank themselves first in their own 'best of' lists?
Early evidence points that way but isn't confirmed as a penalty: per SEO consultant Lily Ray, AI Overviews omitted the self-ranked brand from 83% of answers citing such pages in September 2026, up from 69% in June, based on 100 tracked queries.
Do all analysts agree Google is suppressing self-promoting listicles?
No. Kevin Indig's August analysis found 62% of vendor-authored listicles gained organic traffic since January, and Scrunch measured competitors getting recommended in 24.3% of cases, well under Ray's 70% figure.

Self-ranking “best of” pages — where a company ranks itself first on its own comparison page — are showing up less often in Google AI Overviews, per an Oct. 4 analysis by SEO consultant Lily Ray of Amsive. Ray found AI Overviews omitted the self-ranked brand from 83% of answers citing such pages in September 2026, up from 69% in June, with a competitor recommended instead in 70% of cases, based on a tracked set of 100 “best B2B software” queries. The finding cuts against an August analysis by Kevin Indig that found 62% of vendor-authored listicles gained organic traffic since January, and against Scrunch’s own measurement of a 24.3% competitor-recommendation rate.

Why it matters: Self-ranking content is a common AEO tactic, and this is early, contested evidence that Google's AI Overviews may be working against it rather than a settled trend.

The record: Google AI OverviewsGoogle

Glossary: SEOAI Overviews

Via PPC Land ↗

Posted to the wire October 5, 2026. Edited by Joe Balewski.